
But This War Had Such Promise
Readers of the more than 200 newspapers in the United States and abroad in which Doonesbury appears have enjoyed a privileged awareness of what the Vietnam War might have be as conducted by the denizens of Walden Commune. This latest collection of the popular cartoon strip allows the rest of the nation to witness: a private treaty between quarterback B.D. and an ingratiating Viet Cong terrorist named Phred; slightly stoned war correspondent; the home front protestations of Reverend Scot Sloan, an amiable sophist who likes to be referred to as "the fighting young priest who can speak to the young"; and, of course, the philosophical stumblings of the Sunday Liberal himself, Michael J. Doonesbury. *But This War Has Such Promise* may not remove all the anxiety of foreign entaglement, but it should provide some kind of temporary relief. Garry Trudeau is said to be studying for his master's at Yale. While he remains somewaht of an enigma to his biographers, it is widely known that his boyhood idol was John Foster Dulles.
Beyond its central premise, the book can be read through the connected lenses of Nonfiction. Those themes offer useful points of attention as the characters, ideas, or world develop, especially where the book complicates the expectations of its primary category.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
What the reading experience may hold
A fuller profile for choosing with more confidence—not just another copy of the preview.
Nonfiction
Use these as starting points rather than limits; the most memorable books often stretch beyond their catalog labels.
Catalog signals suggest warfare and conflict, mental-health concerns. These notes may not be complete; consult a publisher or reader-supplied guide when detailed warnings matter.
These notes are inferred from available catalog information and may not be complete. Check a publisher or reader-supplied guide if you need comprehensive warnings.
Dark tone · Steady pace
Works well for a focused weekend or a few concentrated sittings.
A good fit if…
Readers who want a thoughtful experience and enjoy noticing the connections beneath a book’s surface story.
This book's DNA
A visual estimate based on this edition's categories, description, and length. Select a star to explore the signals.
This signal is descriptive, not a rating. It helps compare the kind of reading experience this edition may offer.
Spoiler-Free Emotional Arc
A broad estimate of the book’s emotional rhythm, shown without story events or outcomes.
This visualization is an interpretive estimate based on catalog description, categories, tone, pace, and content signals. It does not describe specific scenes.
A quick reading snapshot
Edition facts and catalog signals to help you decide whether this book fits what you want to read next.
- ISBN-13
- 978-0-0300-7521-6
- Language
- English
- Edition record
- OL5308102M
A more thoughtful way into this book
This guide uses the edition details and category signals above to help you choose deliberately. It does not replace the author's work or a full review.
Works well for a focused weekend or a few concentrated sittings.
Begin with its place in Nonfiction, then notice where the book resists that label.
Read for connection, not completion.
Mark one passage that sharpens the book's central concern and one that complicates it. That tension often reveals more than a quick summary.
Three questions to carry with you
- Whose perspective organizes the story, and whose perspective remains outside it?
- Which sources or lived experiences carry the author’s central argument?
- How does the book change the way you understand its larger subject?
Editorial framework by Wesley Bryan, BookenDeX Founder and Editor.







